Analysis Of Garrett Hardins The Tragedy Of The Commons

Garrett Hardin published in Psychology Today in September 1974. This passage is an excerpt from his popular paper â€Å"The Tragedy of the Commons† as a warning that overpopulation was dangerous due to how limited Earth’s resources are. This theory is reflected in Hardin’s thesis that the rich should do nothing to help the people of poor nations and turn away those trying to come in. Hardin used the imagery of a lifeboat almost filled in a sea full of drowning people to pose and answer a single question, â€Å"what should the lifeboat passengers do?† (290). Hardins answer was to defend the boat against all trying to board. If anyone felt guilty about this course of action they should feel free to swap places with a drowning man and give them their†¦show more content†¦By presenting these arguments Hardin lets the reader come to the conclusion on their own, that they could let no one on. The use of the examples, arguments, and metaphors promoted Ha rdin’s purpose well. However, Hardin relied on his metaphor too much. There was a notable lack of sources in Hardin’s paper. By presenting the reader with definite numbers saying that Earth is reaching its limits Hardin could have brought the reader to his conclusion faster. There are a few more additional places Hardin could have presented data from a source. The subject of America’s current energy crisis is touched on briefly if data was included that explained that America was going to go through more energy than it can make soon it would have cemented Hardin’s main point even more. Hardin also mentioned that one-third of the world was rich and two-thirds considerably poor (290), this should have been cited from a reliable source so it sounded more factual and not just an opinion. Although, this did not stop Hardin from proving his thesis. This paper can be an excellent source for anyone researching into how to fight overpopulation. Hardin provides sev eral other viewpoints that show he did not selectively choose evidence or distort it. Hardin proceeds from point to point logically which allowed the reader to comprehend the main idea effortlessly. The author glided to how the people of poorShow MoreRelatedAnalysis Of Garrett Hardins Tragedy Of The Commons892 Words   |  4 Pagesof the world is growing rapidly, so the question we must ask, are we going to run into a problem where there are too many people in this world and not enough resources to accompany this rapid growth in population? In the article â€Å"Tragedy of the Commons† written by Garrett Hardin, Hardin believes that the population problem cannot be solved in a technical way because the problem involves questions of human freedoms and rights, both of which are issues of morality as opposed to scientific fact. He goesRead MoreAnalysis Of Octavia Butler s Series Of The Parables1508 Words   |  7 Pages Thesis Description The tragedy of the commons shown in the speculative literature of Octavia Butler provides readers with a window of insight into what is necessary for a community to fall apart as well as a guide for what is necessary to build a sustainable community in a broken, imperfect world. This provided guide, in conjunction with the works of scholars such as Garrett Hardin and Eleanor Ostrom, can be used as a mode of processing the tragedy of the commons plaguing worldwide current eventsRead MoreThe North Atlantic : Stopping Cod Stock Depletion2013 Words   |  9 PagesTragedy in the North Atlantic: Stopping Cod Stock Depletion Daniel Vaysburd ENGR 183EW – Discussion 1H †¢ Add in-text citations U.S. fishermen have been harvesting Atlantic cod since the 17th century; in fact, cod was one of the most lucrative products traded during colonial times. Unfortunately, due to high fishing pressure during the past couple of decades, U.S. stocks of Atlantic cod came close to a commercial collapse in the mid-1990s, so a major effort to rebuild these stocks was implementedRead MoreLifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer3380 Words   |  14 PagesLifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer One of the most important issues facing the world today is the issue of the poor. There are many things that can be done about this issue, however much of the world is torn between wanting to help and not knowing how to go about it. This is the issue that is presented in the two essays - Garrett Hardin’s â€Å"Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor,† andRead MorePublic Health Vs. Federal Law2197 Words   |  9 Pagesmandatory immunizations on populations have been debatable with respect to public health law in the United States. One argued topic is whether the level of authority to administer such mandates resides at the federal or state or state level. An analysis of the United States Constitution provides some clarity. The role of the Federal Government is somewhat limited with regards to public health, and its role marks a clear distinction from state and local authority over health matters. The CommerceRead MorePaul Krugman Microcononomics 16-172 940 Words   |  12 PagesRivalrous (or Rival) Consumption: Does providing the good for one more person mean less for somebody else, or is the marginal cost of providing it to one more person equal to zero? 18 37 Four Types of Goods: Private Goods, Public Goods, Common Resources, and Artificially-Scarce Goods 38 Markets Only Supply Private Goods Efficiently Goods that are both excludable and rivalrous in consumption are private goods that potentially can be efficiently produced and consumed in a competitive